Monday, February 28, 2005

Good Ideas, Bad Receptions

If you are like me (and really, if you are not, what good are you?) you have looked at the current system of textbook publishing and said "Damn!?!?!" Public schools spend lots of money deciding on, ordering and distributing text books that are often out of date by the time they are in classrooms. They then have to decide each year if the books they are using are old enough in content and condition to embarrass the education system and if the new editions are good enough to justify replacing the old ones.

It is even worse with University level books because the publishers make pathetic changes like page numbering and exercise order nearly every year and since not every student resells his or her books there is a constant "need" for college bookstores to reorder expensive new books.

I, like many people have seen this state of affairs and thought: "Why don't they set up textbooks electronically?" They could be updated easily, work on numerous platforms from portable handheld to home or library PCs and it would be cheaper to give kids a simple handheld to do them for several years and all subjects than to keep buying expensive textbooks. I believe they tried something similar with laptops in Maine that met initial criticism but has won converts even without electronic textbooks. They could be designed to check in each morning to see if they have been reported lost or stolen. If it were, it could stop working and let someone know the I.P. number it was using. Those that were not used in a reasonable time could periodically beep to alert the owner if lost. It turns out that kids are far more responsible with their gadgets than adults give them credit for anyway and since the material could be available to kids even if they "forget" their device on the bus there would be no incentive to do so (would you believe - the dog encrypted my homework?). Add some messaging and discussion software to the device and kids might even fear loosing them.

And, if you are like me, you have mentioned this idea to people, usually older people, and been given the "Aren't you cute to think that technology can replace textbooks?" look. They may have even tried to explain to you that computers are expensive things (like textbooks are cheap) for adult working environments not toys for school or they blathered off something about information overload (I have never heard a good explanation of what this is - it sounds like something a moron would complain about).

Well, the joke is on them. In a recent BBC article a pilot project in Kenya this exact thing is happening. An interesting quote at the end of the article states:

"Why in this age when most people do most research using the internet are students still using textbooks? The fact that we are doing this in a rural developing country is very exciting - as they need it most."

Indeed. If you also take into account this article about the shrinking digital divide we might just find developing nations leapfrogging our agricultural era education systems. In 20 years we may see African aid workers coming here to teach North American schools how to incorporate student and class blogs and other software into the curriculum because we have been sitting here for two decades saying "Those suggestions are new and therefore silly. You can't use technology to solve all your problems."

No but you can try - you won't fail at everything. Is that not what technology is about?


At Wed. Mar. 02, 06:02:00 p.m. 2005, Blogger Eric Grumbles said...

You think that's bad? Go do some research and find out how the content for textbooks is created. I suspect that Canada is at least as bad as the US, perhaps worse. I cannot recommend enough Diane Ravitch's book The Language Police. It is quite frightening honestly.

At Mon. Mar. 07, 01:45:00 a.m. 2005, Blogger Apesnake said...

Like sausages and law. Don't ask how they are made.

At Sun. Oct. 02, 12:14:00 a.m. 2005, Blogger jon said...

book memory school are so expensive. I agree, We have been looking for book memory school all night for a new book memory school class but havent been able to track down used book memory school that I can afford. Anyway, I enjoyed looking at you book memory school blog...


At Mon. Oct. 03, 06:35:00 a.m. 2005, Blogger jon said...

I was searching for must love dog info and found this post. I agree totally!



Post a Comment

<< Home


Day By Day© by Chris Muir.